Critical Reenchatment without the Astrology: Rescuing Taras, Rescuing Le Grice by Wayne Martin Mellinger, Ph.D.
Rescuing Tarnas, Rescuing Le Grice: Critical Reenchantment Without the Astrology
Research Note — Dionysian Naturalism / Western Esoteric Traditions Project
Wayne Martin Mellinger, Ph.D.
v4 — final
1. The Problem
Richard Tarnas's Cosmos and Psyche: Intimations of a New World View (Viking, 2006) contains two projects that need to be analytically separated. Its opening chapters — roughly the first seventy pages — offer a compelling historical and philosophical diagnosis of Western modernity: the emergence of the autonomous modern subject, the mechanization and objectification of nature, the progressive disenchantment of the cosmos, and the resulting separation of psyche from world. The remaining five hundred pages then propose archetypal astrology as the empirical demonstration of a participatory cosmos capable of curing that condition. Kieron Le Grice, Tarnas's student and the founding co-editor of Archai: The Journal of Archetypal Cosmology, performs a structurally similar move in The Archetypal Cosmos (Floris Books, 2010): a genuinely ambitious process-relational cosmology in service of the same discipline. Stanislav Grof, Tarnas's collaborator of five decades, makes a related claim from the clinical and psychedelic-research side.
The appropriate response to all three is neither wholesale acceptance nor wholesale dismissal, but critical appropriation — the same posture appropriate to contemporary esoteric writers such as Gordon White, whose Star.Ships: A Prehistory of the Spirits (2016) indicts the progress-narrative of scientific materialism, and Peter Grey, whose Apocalyptic Witchcraft (2013, Scarlet Imprint) frames witchcraft explicitly as opposition to the hierarchies and technologies of the modern world amid ecological crisis. Both are worth mining for phenomenological observation and critique of modernity without either being accepted as an indivisible metaphysical package.
This matters because the reflexive alternative — dismissing Cosmos and Psyche simply because its destination is astrology — reproduces a specific historical pattern that Wouter J. Hanegraaff's scholarship has spent decades examining: the construction of esoteric currents as the academy's "rejected knowledge," expelled not on case-by-case evidentiary grounds but as the constitutive Other against which post-Enlightenment rationality defined itself. Hanegraaff's point is not that rejected knowledge was secretly true, and it should not be read that way here. It is that the historical category of rejection should not be allowed to determine in advance what deserves examination — the corrective to premature exclusion is careful adjudication, not blanket inclusion. That is the middle territory this note tries to hold: neither epistemic exclusion nor esoteric credulity.
2. Tarnas within the Critical Tradition
2.1 The historical production of the modern worldview
Tarnas's opening argument is that modernity did not simply discover a neutral description of reality. Through the Renaissance, Reformation, Scientific Revolution, and Enlightenment, Western culture progressively reorganized the relationship between the knowing subject and the external world. This produced extraordinary gains: differentiating subject from object made rigorous scientific investigation possible; nature could be studied independent of ecclesiastical authority; the autonomous individual acquired unprecedented epistemic and moral standing.
The same process, on Tarnas's account, produced a corresponding loss. As consciousness, agency, purpose, and value became increasingly located within the human subject, the external cosmos was progressively emptied of these qualities. Nature became matter in motion governed by impersonal law; meaning became something humans possess rather than something the world discloses.
2.2 Affinities, not debts
This argument bears a striking resemblance to a recognizable tradition of criticism of modernity, though the resemblance should be stated as conceptual affinity rather than demonstrated influence — establishing that Tarnas actually drew on these thinkers would require textual evidence this note does not have.
- Weber's disenchantment thesis (Entzauberung) is the closest parallel: a cosmos evacuated of intrinsic meaning as the price of rationalization.
- Marx's concept of alienation resonates at a structural level, though Tarnas relocates it from political economy to the relationship between psyche and cosmos.
- Horkheimer and Adorno's critique of instrumental reason in Dialectic of Enlightenment — reason mobilized for mastery turning back to dominate the subject too — has a clear affinity with Tarnas's account of the domination of nature as correlate of the domination of the modern self.
- Heidegger's critique of technological enframing (Gestell) — the reduction of the world to Bestand, standing-reserve available only for calculation, against a world that discloses itself (aletheia) — resonates closely with Tarnas's complaint about a world reduced to measurement.
- Whitehead's attack on the "bifurcation of nature" — his objection to splitting reality into a public, quantifiable realm and a private, subjective realm to which meaning and color are relegated — is close kin to Tarnas's complaint that meaning has been evacuated from the world and relocated entirely inside the subject.
What matters is not that Tarnas derived his position from this tradition, but that his critique is not an isolated esoteric complaint about modern science — it can be placed in conversation with a broad and intellectually substantial body of criticism of modernity's costs, regardless of derivation. That placement is what lets the diagnosis be extracted from the book whole and defended on its own terms, independent of anything that follows.
2.3 The paradox of the autonomous modern self
Tarnas's most self-contained insight is that modernity's liberation and modernity's pathology emerge from the same historical process. The modern individual becomes progressively liberated from an enchanted cosmos while simultaneously becoming existentially isolated within a disenchanted one. Humanity acquires unprecedented power over nature precisely as nature becomes increasingly experienced as external to humanity. Human beings experience consciousness, meaning, beauty, and sacredness, yet inhabit a cosmos conventionally described as intrinsically indifferent to all of them. The stronger the concentration of meaning inside the autonomous subject, the more radical the subject's separation from the cosmos it inhabits. This formulation requires no astrology whatsoever, and it is arguably the single most portable idea in the book.
2.4 Disenchantment and ecological crisis
The claim here needs care. A disenchanted world is not necessarily an environmentally destructive one, and enchanted cultures have certainly damaged their environments — a direct causal claim (disenchantment produces ecological destruction) is historically indefensible. The defensible claim concerns moral perception, or what might be called moral affordances: cosmologies make particular relationships with nature easier or harder to perceive as legitimate. A forest understood exclusively as timber inventory presents itself differently from a forest simultaneously encountered as habitat, watershed, and living presence. Modern capitalism, colonialism, industrialization, and fossil-fuel technologies are indispensable to any serious explanation of ecological destruction — but the objectification of nature supplied a cultural and epistemological framework within which instrumental exploitation could appear rational. That raises a question of direct relevance to religious naturalism: can nature become an object of reverence again without abandoning the epistemic achievements of science? That question survives completely independent of astrology.
2.5 The participatory alternative
Tarnas's response to disenchantment is the recovery of a participatory epistemology: the knowing subject is itself part of the reality being known, and consciousness emerged within nature rather than observing it from outside. This critique of Cartesian subject-object dualism is philosophically productive independent of Tarnas's eventual cosmology — phenomenology (Merleau-Ponty), pragmatism, ecological philosophy, process thought, and enactivist cognitive science (Varela, Thompson, and Rosch's The Embodied Mind) have all challenged the picture of an isolated mind representing an entirely external world. Participation need not mean abandoning knowledge for mysticism; it can mean recognizing that scientific measurement, however powerful, does not exhaust every legitimate mode of encountering a forest, grief, ritual, or the night sky.
3. Where the Astrological Demonstration Breaks
The decisive problem arises when Tarnas moves from criticizing disenchantment to claiming that archetypal astrology provides empirical evidence for the participatory cosmos he has philosophically described. These are logically separate propositions: demonstrating that Cartesian dualism is inadequate does not demonstrate an archetypal universe; demonstrating the historical reality of disenchantment does not establish synchronicity as an objective ordering principle; showing that archetypal interpretation can illuminate psychological experience does not demonstrate correlations between planetary configurations and historical events. The astrological chapters bear an empirical burden the philosophical chapters do not, and several distinct problems undermine that burden:
The disconfirmation problem. As an empirical hypothesis, archetypal astrology suffers from a serious problem of disconfirmation: the semantic range of its archetypes — Saturn can signify limitation, structure, authority, discipline, or mortality; Uranus can signify disruption, liberation, revolution, or sudden technological change — makes it difficult to specify in advance what observations would count decisively against the proposed correlations. This is a criticism confined to Tarnas's specific empirical claim, not an assertion that all worthwhile knowledge must be Popper-falsifiable; the project of recovering phenomenological, hermeneutic, and symbolic modes of understanding elsewhere in this note depends on that distinction holding.
The retrospective-selection problem. Tarnas's evidentiary method is overwhelmingly retrospective — identify a known event, then locate the transit that correlates. A more persuasive demonstration would specify beforehand what should occur, in what window, by what criteria, and what would count against the hypothesis. Retrospective pattern recognition is especially vulnerable to confirmation bias.
The multiple-comparisons problem. With numerous planetary bodies, aspect types, temporal windows, and archetypal meanings available, the space of possible retrospective correspondences is enormous. Striking matches will occur simply as a matter of combinatorics, and the qualitative, narrative methodology on offer does not control for this.
The conflation of interpretive power with empirical demonstration. Tarnas is an unusually gifted writer, and his archetypal descriptions make historical correspondences feel compelling. But narrative elegance is not independent evidence of correlation; the beauty that makes Cosmos and Psyche pleasurable to read can perform persuasive work the methodology itself cannot sustain.
None of this demonstrates that archetypal astrology is necessarily false. It establishes the more limited but sufficient conclusion that Tarnas has not provided evidence warranting the confidence he places in it — and that disenchantment can be real, and a participatory relationship with nature desirable, without any of this being true.
4. Grof: Phenomenon and Explanation
Stanislav Grof's related claim — that a synthesis of archetypal psychology and transit astrology represents the most promising strategy for the future of psychiatry and depth psychology — draws on decades of clinical and psychedelic-research material, a fifty-year collaboration with Tarnas beginning in 1976.
Grof's underlying investigative work deserves to be taken seriously on its own terms: he studied non-ordinary states of consciousness that conventional psychiatry frequently marginalized or dismissed, and some of what he documented may eventually call for conceptual frameworks different from those now dominant. But phenomenon and explanation need to be kept separate. Grof may have encountered real and psychologically consequential phenomena without correctly explaining their origin; non-ordinary states can be genuine without establishing any particular metaphysical interpretation placed on them, astrological or otherwise. Great intellectual pioneers sometimes see something important before they can adequately explain what they have seen — that is a better lens for reading Grof than treating him as simply another failed astrologer.
The specific astrological claim, though, faces the decisive methodological question directly: were the astrological correspondences in these sessions ever assessed under blinded conditions, by raters unaware of the transit data, against an appropriate control? Absent that, there is no way to know whether astrologically congruent material occurred at rates exceeding what retrospective interpretation alone would produce. Grof's own description of the evidence as convincing him "beyond any reasonable doubt" is not a claim this methodology can support, however sincerely held — and the five-decade convergence of belief between two close collaborators is a real biographical fact worth noting, but shared long-term commitment is not a substitute for independent replication.
5. Le Grice: A Metaphysical Architecture, Not a Solved Problem
The Archetypal Cosmos addresses a real theoretical gap left open by Cosmos and Psyche. Tarnas does not merely assert an archetypal cosmology in passing — the whole of Cosmos and Psyche is an extended attempt to establish one. What Le Grice does differently is supply a more systematic metaphysical architecture capable of making such correspondences intelligible in the first place: drawing on Jung's later writing on synchronicity and the unus mundus, Whitehead-adjacent process thought, David Bohm's implicate order, and Brian Swimme's evolutionary cosmology, he asks what kind of universe would have to be true for archetypal correspondences between psyche and cosmos to make sense at all.
What is genuinely valuable here, independent of the astrology:
- The critique of substance metaphysics — a relational, process-oriented, even proto-psychic cosmos against a purely mechanistic one is a live position in contemporary philosophy of mind (panpsychism, Russellian monism), fully evaluable on naturalistic grounds without any astrological commitment.
- The participatory epistemology inherited from Tarnas's Passion of the Western Mind — the knower as co-constitutive participant, with real precedent in Merleau-Ponty and enactivist cognitive science.
- The diagnosis of a meaning-crisis requiring cosmological, not merely psychological, resolution — a felt need for a cosmos not indifferent to value, a need religious naturalism, process theology, and deep ecology have also identified.
But a universe capable of accommodating astrology does not demonstrate that astrology occurs. Even if reality is thoroughly relational, processual, and saturated with interiority, nothing necessarily follows about Saturn, Pluto, natal charts, or transits — an additional, independent empirical argument is required to establish those specific correlations, and Le Grice does not supply one; he inherits it from the astrological tradition and gives it cosmological cover.
This is the pattern worth naming because it recurs across the esoteric corpus: a sophisticated criticism of modern metaphysics becomes attached to a particular esoteric practice, and the strength of the criticism is then allowed to lend unearned credibility to a practice that requires independent demonstration. The inference is invalid. One can reject mechanistic materialism in full and reject astrology in full; nothing in Le Grice's cosmology forces the conjunction.
6. Mining and Naturalizing: A Protocol
The procedure running through this note can be stated as an explicit, transferable rule for the wider Western esoteric corpus — Tarnas, Grof, Le Grice, Jung, Hillman, Gordon White, Peter Grey, and beyond:
Retain the diagnosis. Test the explanation. Naturalize the insight. Refuse the unsupported ontology.
Applied here: retain Tarnas's critique of disenchantment, the paradox of the autonomous self, and the search for participatory ways of knowing. Test Grof's astrological interpretation against ordinary standards of evidence rather than against the emotional weight of the experiences it was built to explain. Naturalize archetype not as scientific fact but as hermeneutic category: archetypes can be retained modestly as recurring symbolic configurations through which human beings organize and interpret experience, following Hillman's understanding of soul as a way of seeing rather than a metaphysical substance. Their usefulness as interpretive tools for reading myth, culture, and personal narrative does not require establishing them as inherited psychic structures, autonomous metaphysical entities, or cosmic principles — that stronger claim is precisely the one this note is declining to make. And refuse the unsupported ontology in Le Grice: a relational cosmology that could accommodate astrology is not evidence that astrology is true.
7. The Naturalizing Move
| Retained (naturalizable) | Set aside (unsupported empirical claim) |
|---|---|
| The disenchantment diagnosis, in affinity with Weber/Marx/Frankfurt School/Heidegger/Whitehead | Planetary transits correlating with historical events |
| The paradox of autonomy: liberation from an enchanted cosmos as simultaneous isolation within a disenchanted one | Natal charts as diagnostic of individual psychology |
| The critique of mechanistic, substance-based metaphysics (Le Grice) | Archetypal readings of psychedelic/holotropic sessions as astrological confirmation (Grof) |
| A participatory, embodied epistemology (Merleau-Ponty, enactivism) | Synchronicity as evidence of a cosmic ordering principle tied to celestial bodies specifically |
| The ecological point: cosmological vocabulary shapes what relationships with nature seem rational (moral affordances) | Astrology as a validated predictive or diagnostic technique |
| Archetype as hermeneutic category — a way of reading myth and experience (Hillman) | Le Grice's process cosmology treated as entailing, rather than merely being compatible with, archetypal astrology |
What is lost, and should be named as a loss rather than smuggled back in through the cosmology, is the predictive and diagnostic ambition that gives archetypal astrology its practical appeal — the sense that one could look outward and find confirmation of an inward pattern. That ambition does not survive naturalization, in Tarnas, Grof, or Le Grice, because the gap is evidentiary, not metaphysical.
8. Toward Critical Reenchantment
Tarnas may be most valuable precisely where his own project is least persuasive. He correctly identifies the problem of disenchantment but need not have correctly identified its solution. His failure points toward the harder task this note has been trying to work out: recovering participation, sacredness, wonder, and cosmological belonging without claiming more about the universe than the evidence permits. The challenge is not simply reenchantment. It is reenchantment without credulity — participation without credulity, sacredness without supernaturalism, ecstasy without epistemic inflation, mythology without literalism, naturalism without reductionism.
This note complements the existing annotated bibliography and intellectual genealogy of Dionysian Naturalism (2014–2026) by supplying the transferable protocol that genealogy's other case studies can use: a parallel treatment of Jung's own writing on synchronicity, or of Starhawk's ritual magic, would likely follow the same structure worked out here.
Tarnas's answer need not be ours. His question should be.

Comments
Post a Comment