NATURE RELIGIONS AND REVOLUTIONARY SOCIAL CHANGE:
NATURE RELIGIONS AND
REVOLUTIONARY SOCIAL CHANGE:
ADVANCING A PRACTICAL
THEOLOGY FOR SPIRITUAL ACTIVISM
By Wayne Martin Mellinger, Ph.D.
INTRODUCTION
By far the
greatest challenges that humanity has ever confronted are global climate change
and the other environmental problems created by modern industrial
civilization. Monthly the news seems to
get worse as we learn that the ecological crisis is far bigger than we first
thought and the time left before we face a potential environmental collapse is
far shorter. Some well-informed
researchers say that it is already too late to avoid catastrophic destruction
of civilization or to “save the planet”.
Joanna Macy, a
prominent Buddhist eco-activist, labels our current era “The Great Turning”
because it can be a period of transition from the old industrial system, which
must be brought to an end, and the new sustainable system, which must emerge
very soon1. As she notes, the
Earth is both the storehouse and the sewer for our industrial economy, which
depends on an ever-increasing consumption of resources. The Great Turning is an ecological revolution
which must happen within a few years and which must involve not just our
political economic system, but also the values and habits which enable it.
Albert
Einstein is often attributed as stating that: “No problem can be solved from
the same level of consciousness that created it”2. To reach a
sustainable society will require a vastly different worldview, a different
psychological comportment and a higher level of consciousness than that which
we currently have, and therefore we also require a cognitive, perceptual and
spiritual revolution. Specifically, we
must awaken to our spiritual connections to other living beings and to our
planet, re-think the moral and ethical foundations of modern industrial
civilization and eliminate the materialist mindset and radical individualism
which so often guide our lives.
Some readers
might query: “Spiritual revolution?
Really? Must we bring matters of “spirit” into our struggles to deal
with climate change?” While it is not
impossible for those who are secular to achieve an ecological consciousness,
humans seem to naturally distinguish between that which is sacred and that
which is profane. And the heart of
spirituality is the development of this sense of the sacred. To say that Nature is sacred is to insist
that it must be treated with reverence and respect and never violated. It is of utmost importance. It is holy and ultimate. Employing a conception of Nature as sacred
can radically alter our relationship to the planet, and even if this
sacralization process is built upon a leap of the imagination, this
conceptualization can be a purposeful act which promotes the ecological
consciousness so central to the new worldview we must cultivate.
Several years
ago I began to build my personal theology and religious practice, and this
essay is a part of that ongoing effort3. Given my passionate concerns for the health
and integrity of our planet and my spiritual interests in developing a sense of
Nature as sacred, I long ago initiated a deep examination of “Nature Religions”4. These approaches to spirituality, which
regard our natural world as inherently sacred, include some of the most ancient
religions on our planet, such as those of most indigenous peoples (such as
Native Americans), the classical Pagan traditions of pre-Christian Europe and
their “re-birth” in the form of Wicca, Neo-Paganism and Druidry. Nature Religions include approaches that
embrace belief in the supernatural (such as versions of Paganism, Wicca and
Druidry, which maintain belief in transcendent deities) and naturalistic forms
(such as the various forms of Religious Naturalism) which typically reject
belief in the supernatural.
Many followers
of Nature Religions bring an ecological consciousness to their religious
sensibilities. They are reclaiming the primal story of our sacred evolving
universe, of our home on planet Earth which abounds with diverse and
magnificent life-forms, and of our spiritual connections to all that
exists. Awareness of the boundless
creativity of the cosmos has triggered a renewal of an ancient sacred vision of
our natural world. Their sense of
kinship with all that exists and powerful feelings of belonging nurture an
ethic of caring in which humans must tread gently as they walk upon these
hallowed grounds. As “Earth-centered”
traditions, Nature Religions celebrate the rhythms and cycles of our world and
place great importance upon protecting wilderness areas and biological
diversity. For adherents to these
religious approaches, the entire Universe is a “sacred living system” and its
destruction is desecration.
Lately, Nature
Religions have moved beyond their initial grassroots, do-it-yourself phase and
are quickly becoming institutionalized.
For example, the US armed services now offer Pagan Chaplains and the
Cherry Hill Seminary offers M. Div.
degrees in both Pagan and Naturalistic approaches. Academic conferences, textbook materials, and
well-developed liturgies and theological reflections all provide evidence of
formalization and professionalization process.
Institutional
religions tend to come in four varieties—reactionary, conservative, progressive
and revolutionary. Reactionaries claim
to have The One Right Way, tolerate no questioning of their take on scriptural
truth and often advocate the return to a theocracy in which their one true
religion will rule. Conservatives are
comfortable with the faith of their fathers, draw strength within the
protective walls of their synagogues, churches, mosques, and temples and
steadfastly defend the status quo.
Progressives are open to the world and to new interpretations of ancient
myths and are reformist in their political orientations. Revolutionaries want to jettison the
narratives of their cultures and radically question the claims of all clerical
authorities. They insist on a total re-thinking
of our religious sensibilities and demand new organizing myths. A sense of urgency with the mounting problems
of the world forces these people to call for rapid and immediate
transformations in our vision of the sacred and our worldly social system.
INSURGENT
NATURE RELIGIONS
Throughout
history and across the globe religions are central carriers of tradition and
thus typically prevent revolutionary social change. Sociologists often highlight these
“functional” roles, including the socialization of successive generations in
the moral and ethical values of current generations, the elaboration and
justification of worldviews, the legitimization of political elites and the
establishment of moral boundaries between good and evil, clean and dirty, and
sacred and profane.
The magnitude
of the environmental crisis compounded by the time limitations that exist
before we face a total environmental collapse, lead me to the conclusion that
revolution is required. The realization
that the corporate elite will not respond appropriately to avert catastrophe
reinforces this commitment to revolutionary social change. As revolutionaries we must steer the populace
towards a better world and lead the transition from a period of life-denying
human practices to a period of life-affirming practices.
To
purposefully create a revolutionary religion one must have a clear sense of the
traditions of the existing social order that must be eliminated. Revolutionary religion must socialize the
young with different values, promote new worldviews and challenge existing
elites. Revolutionary religion does not function to support the status quo but
instead to create new societal forms. It
should aid and support change agents as they struggle to make a better world
and mobilize the masses to participate in social movement activities.
These are
times demanding revolutionary religion.
As we increasingly come to realize that our planet is dying, a massive
spiritual awakening is sweeping across the globe. Today many are not just insisting on the
holiness of this world but are adopting or creating “Earth-centered” spiritual
traditions which are revolutionary in their political orientations. In the social worlds I inhabit along the
central coast of California, which includes many people who typically were
involved in the progressive variety of religion, there has been a marked shift
to the revolutionary end of the spectrum.
Insurgent Nature Religions are on the rise!
As previously
noted, Nature Religions can be divided into two broad categories,
supernaturalistic and naturalistic. Due to a pervasive skepticism which I
believe keeps me grounded in a verifiable and empirical reality, I am
developing a version of naturalistic Nature Religion, which I call Dionysian
Naturalism. It is a “liberation
theology” which explicitly embraces the revolutionary social change required to
reach a sustainable society.
“Naturalism” is term which in this context
brings two aspects to its meaning: (1) the natural world is all that exists
(there being no supernatural realm) and (2) science is a good way (although not
the only way) to understand that natural world.
With their worldviews framed by the logic and methods of scientific
discovery, naturalistic Nature Religions celebrate the great story of the
evolutionary unfolding of our cosmos.
They find the sacred in this world.
Participants remain highly skeptical about supernatural
metaphysics. Yet in venerating this
world, many are reviving the ancient Pagan notion of animus mundi—the
soul of the world -- and this form of enchantment softens the materialism,
reductionism and determinism which are sometimes espoused by
scientifically-minded people.
Dionysus was
the ancient Greek god of wine and ecstasy whose followers were well known for
sacred rituals which were wildly festive and transgressive to such an extent
that they approached drunken orgies. We
now know that the Mystery Religions of ancient Greece often consumed powerful
hallucinogenic plants, such as ergot and Belladonna, with sacred
intent--perhaps a legacy of earlier shamanic traditions. Dionysus was the “Giver of Ecstasy” who
transported his followers through an altered state of consciousness to a
mystical rapture, which included wild dancing and other trance-induced
activities. Dionysian Naturalists
reclaim “ecstatic religion” and the potential of sacramental entheogen use, as
well as the use of other shamanic and mystical practices. For me “Dionysian” essentially involves being
transported in a non-ordinary and ecstatic state of consciousness to a sacred
realm.
I place
Dionysian Naturalism in what Caitlin and John Matthews call the “Western
Mystery Tradition”, a spiritual current that runs through Western culture,
beginning from the native, shamanic lore of many northern and western European
people, through classical Paganism, and the esoteric Hermetic traditions, such
as medieval Alchemy and high magic5.
The Mathews argue that this tradition preserves an ancient and perennial
Earth wisdom that is still a part of the West's spiritual inheritance. Dionysian Naturalism fuses this Pagan and “Earth-centered”
tradition to a modern scientific worldview.
I attend a Unitarian Universalist (UU) church
in Santa Barbara, and 20 years ago progressive humanism was still the dominant
theology. Nowadays, especially among the
younger congregants, “Religious Naturalism” is more common and increasingly
humanism is regarded as anthropocentric.
In 1985 UUs adopted their last principle, generally known as the Seventh
Principle: “Respect for the interdependent web of all existence of which we are
part” and a sixth source was adopted in 1995: “Spiritual teaching of
earth-centered traditions which celebrate the sacred circle of life and
instruct us to live in harmony with the rhythms of nature”. While Unitarian Universalists are pioneers in
“liberal religion” (thus embodying the “progressive” version of religion
mentioned above) and the first mainline religion to truly embrace Nature
Religions, increasingly many are embracing revolutionary stances!
As noted, this
essay highlights several contributions religion can bring to social movement
struggles for justice and transformational politics. These are times which
demand “engaged spirituality”, in which religious people actively engage with
the world in order to transform it in positive ways while finding inspiration,
moral support and guidance in their spiritual beliefs and practices. To those ends I advance a “practical
theology of social change” focused on our intentional interventions to change
the world (“praxis”), and outline some of its operating principles and
spiritual practices. In later sections I
further explore some of these spiritual practices, including prophecy,
contemplative reflection, and direct action.
This model of transformational politics and sacred activism reveals a
few of the best offerings that religion brings to revolutionary social change
A PRACTICAL THEOLOGY OF SOCIAL CHANGE
I draw upon a
practical theology of social change in which faith communities and other groups
engage in grassroots community organizing to empower displaced, marginalized
and silenced groups to transform their own lives and the structural conditions
which deny them justice. This model is
grounded in congregations and neighborhoods and transforms global issues into
local issues. “Practical” in this
religious context does not mean “useful” or efficient”, but instead means
“based upon the notion of praxis”--a somewhat intellectual concept emerging
from philosophical discourses emphasizing theoretically-informed and
change-oriented interventions6.
Practical theology
as an academic discipline used to focus on the religious actions of clergy and
other pastoral concerns. Today there is
an increased focus on “lived religion” -- that is how people do religion. Praxis happens when we “walk the talk” and
“live our values”. It also implies
taking insights derived in classrooms and bringing them to the real world. Typically praxis is conceived as a cycle of
action – reflection in which we closely monitor the outcomes of our
behavior. Often praxis can refer to
novel actions (as opposed to routine habits) in which we evaluate the ethical
consequences of our conduct.
The praxis
cycle of action – reflection forms the foundation of my theology of social
change. We act and then reflect, and
then, based upon our insights and evaluations, we act again. If our values are
based upon an ecological consciousness we will understand that our well-being
is linked to the well-being of the whole and that we all face the same
fate. Interconnection and
interdependence are defining attributes of our complex web of existence.
This approach
is greatly needed at this historical moment if we are to successfully address
our environmental problems and create a sustainable society. Something so seemingly small as momentarily
pausing to contemplate our values and intentions, and the unintended
consequences of our actions, can have significant impact when performed by
millions of people. Our personal choices
bear unanticipated transformational power.
By fully embracing the sacred practice of praxis we become powerful
change agents having a positive influence on the world.
GUIDING
PRINCIPLES
We are all intimately connected and we need each other for our health,
happiness and survival. Our bonds with
each other bind us into what Martin Luther King, Jr;. called a “inescapable
network of mutuality”7. The
well-being of each of us is linked to the well-being of the whole and we all
face the same fate. Relationships define
our lives. Yet each of us is able to
make a difference to the whole. We are
kin with all other life forms, sharing similar compositions and made from the
same stardust. We celebrate the circle
of life and know that we must live in harmony with the rhythms of the natural
world. The following principles are based on how Nature
works.
This is a
holistic framework for understanding complex systems, focusing on relationships
and interdependence, with the cyclical nature of existence mirrored in the
action - reflection cycles. The
reflective processes serve as forms of feedback loops, which are standard in
ecosystems. Rootedness in the elements
of place helps to keep our bearings as we re-acquaint ourselves with the soils
beneath our feet, the waters which flow in our creeks and rivers, the air which
feeds our lungs and the fires which ignite the passions of our hearts. We must connect with the soul of our local
landscapes and draw inspiration from our surroundings.
The guiding
principles of this practical theology of social change are outlined here in a
roughly sequential manner, but this should not be seen as a simple cookbook
recipe for changing the world:
1.
As
people of faith we take responsibility for the state of the world and know that
our actions make a difference;
2.
We
bear witness to the injustices of the world and listen to the songs of sorrow
of those who suffer (including our non-human friends).
3.
We
thoroughly gather information on the problems we are concerned with, including
carefully listening to the voices of our “enemies”, knowing that nothing
reveals our moral character as much as our encounters with our adversaries.
Listening to our adversaries requires that we “step outside ourselves” (Greek
“Ekstasis”). Fighting ignorance and
raising consciousness is the best way to confront tyranny.
4.
Grounded in congregations, neighborhoods and
communities, and inspired by our own witnessing of injustice, we undertake
grassroots community organizing to empower silenced, displaced and marginalized
people to transform their own lives and the structural conditions which deny
them justice.
5.
As
diverse communities we come together to affirm our shared values, which we
strive to always put into action. The
revolution is how we live our lives. If
we want a Beloved Earth Community that is just, compassionate and sustainable
we must “prefigure” that world today in our behavior. We also come together as communities to
decide which issues to tackle and by what means, and then to evaluate their
successfulness;
6.
Prophetic
critique of our existing society allows us to name “what's not working” and
prophetic envisioning allows us to imagine “how it should be” (The Beloved
Earth Community). As a spiritual
practice, prophecy enables communities to access the sacred in order to
critically evaluate their existing society in terms of social justice,
ecological sustainability and compassion, and points to the systems of
domination and oppression and “calls out” the powerful elites who benefit from
them. Prophesy also energizes
communities with hopes that their visions of a better world can yet be achieved.
7.
This
is a model of social change in which we aim to transform the very structures of
our social world and get to the root causes of our social ills through
strategic direct actions. While
charitable acts are often needed, they are not enough! These strategic direct actions are spiritual
practices embodying our life-affirming values, including non-violence,
compassion, social justice and respect for the dignity and worth of all life
forms. Being “Dionysian”, we hope to
insert celebratory, carnivaleque and transgressive pleasures into our
transformative actions.
8.
Through
contemplative practices, such as prayer, meditation and reflective discernment,
we make contact with the sacred to clarify our intentions, affirm our values,
evaluate the ethical outcomes of our behavior and potentially decide to change
directions. Sacred reflections on our
actions allow us to persistently return to our goals with fresh insights until
those goals become reality.
9.
Awareness
of our interconnections with the web of all existences keeps us committed to
the common good and to the life of our planet and working to eliminate the
poisonous effects of ego.
Most social
movement activists do not yet fully incorporate spiritual practices into their
organizing. There is often a “hush-hush”
around issues of faith in progressive communities for fear of hearing about
fundamentalism. This practical theology
of social change brings to community organizers and social activists a set of
well-developed spiritual practices which infuse political dissent with
spiritual passion. They elevate the
playing field with thoughtful and compassionate actions. They link our actions to a history of
value-rich ideals and noble intentions.
Most importantly by demanding that we thoroughly live our values they
shift our behavior with our adversaries.
.
ON SPIRITUAL PRACTICES
Spiritual
practices are tools that allow us to experience the sacred – that which is most
important for our lives. They transform
us in numerous ways – opening our hearts, reducing our anxiety, expanding our
compassion and developing our wisdom.
With clearer minds and calmer bodies, we become aware of those gentle
voices in our heads. In the following sections,
I highlight four spiritual practices found within this practical theology:
praxis itself, prophecy (critique and envisioning), contemplative practices,
and direct action. These practices are,
I believe, some of the best resources that religion has to offer revolutionary
activists.
These
spiritual practices are specific techniques which must be cultivated with
discipline, but eventually become natural ways of being. They are powerful, yet simple, exercises
directly applicable to our lives. If life
is a spiritual journey in which we awaken from our slumber and potentially reach
higher levels of awareness, spiritual practices such as these propel our
progression.
For those who
regard Nature as sacred, how we experience the sacred is often through direct
experiences in wilderness in which we become aware of the interdependence of
the web of existence. This “cosmic
consciousness” is crucial to Nature Religions.
It fills us with awe and wonder as we feel the mystery and majesty of
the natural world, realize our absolute dependence on this world for everything
we need and have, and recognize our humble fragility compared to its vast
powers.
Because much
social movement engagement will happen on our city streets, we must remain
creative in finding ways to bring our particular sense of the sacred to these
struggles. Pagan-inspired and
“Earth-centered” rituals that acknowledge and strengthen our relationships to
the natural world can be useful. In
celebrating the Wheel of the Year, for example, we honor the cycles of Nature. Or through Wiccan practice of “casting a circle” by invoking the four
directions and the four elements, we become more deeply emplaced in our local
settings.
MORE ON
PRAXIS
To do the
right thing I sometimes stop what I’m doing out of habit, contemplate the
(often unintended) consequences of my potential course of action and consider
the ethics involved. When I change my
behavior and put my values into action, I’m engaging in a process philosophers
sometimes refer to as praxis.
With each
action that we take, we make the world.
With each action we take, we potentially make the world better or
worse. Our ordinary activities
count. For it is through these everyday
behaviors that the social world is constituted as an orderly event. The idea of the world as open to
transformation by human intervention is crucial to our conception of
modernity. We are now more aware than
ever before that we can—make that must—construct a different way of social life
for the survival of our species and our planet.
That we are conscious of other imaginal worlds, and conscious that our
actions will create these different worlds are particularly “modern”
phenomenon.
We know that
the social world will change and that these changes will be the result of
changes in our actions. In earlier times
in human history, people thought of the social world as just being “the way it
is” and did not regard it as connected in any significant way to their personal
behavior in everyday life. The social
world was seen to exist “out here”, constraining personal action, but not
really created by it.
While people
can “reproduce” the structure of society by doing what they previously have
done, there is no guarantee that they will.
People are always able to act differently than they do. The possibility for change is inherent in
every act of social reproduction. These
are the spaces in which praxis enters.
Praxis is for me a spiritual practice imbued with holiness because we
let go of ego-driven thinking and consider the common good, thus allowing us to
open our hearts and minds to spiritual possibilities. Praxis is autonomous and creative
intervention which does not reproduce a society structured in dominance.
By performing
acts of praxis, we move away from what Erica Sherover-Marcuse calls a
“mystified consciousness” – our routine and habitual modes of being in the
world which feel good because we have done them so many times before8. These ways of being in the world appear so
normal to us that we are blinded to the fact that our actions reproduce systems
of domination. The road to collective
liberation is found when humans move from a mystified consciousness to an
emancipatory consciousness. This is no
easy task as the habits of oppression and injustice are deeply embedded in our
subjectivity.
A rigorous
process of “unlearning” is necessary in which one scrutinizes the very
suppositions of one's language and one's emotional demeanor in the social
world. We thus begin to cease our
participation in reproducing hierarchy and hatred. To become aware of one's participation in
systems of oppression and to consciously choose to cease that involvement
because one identifies with the downtrodden and disinherited, one stakes a
moral claim that all humans are equal and warrant dignity, respect and
love. This is a spiritual act.
Social
activists, as people committed to changing the world, can greatly benefit from
developing praxis as a spiritual practice.
For some it may mean a shift in focus from the realm of public politics
to the more private realm of everyday life.
Rather than the focus on transforming institutional settings and the
more obviously “structural” features of our society, as change agents typically
do, developing praxis as a routine part of one’s daily life enables the close
scrutiny of supposedly mundane tasks, such as family life, work routines,
consumption patterns, leisure activities and interpersonal relationships.
Of course,
each of these arenas is essential to the composition of modern society and will
be sites rich in potential change. Washing the dishes, one might consider how to
more frugally use the water. Talking to
one’s children one might consider how patriarchy has shaped one’s childrearing
practices. Driving to work one might
again consider how carpooling on some days and using public transportation on
others might benefit air quality. All of
us need to examine our habitual patterns of everyday life with an eye to how
they might contribute to the ills of our world, for it is through these
ordinary activities that “societies” are constituted.
Some questions
and suggestions to help you turn your actions into praxis: Take time to quietly contemplate what you are
doing, for nothing reveals the inadequacies of our behavior as much as
contemplative practices such as prayer and discernment. Consider some of these
questions in your meditation. What are your intentions with this action and
what goal(s) do you hope to achieve?
Does it serve the common good?
How does this action align with your values? Is it an expression of compassion? What is your vision of a better world? How do
current actions contribute to social problems, social injustice and ecological
devastation? What are potential
unintended consequences of your action?
Does this action support ecological integrity? What are alternative courses of action that
you could take?
PROPHESY
Biblical
scholar Marcus Borg argues that a prophet is one who speaks by divine
inspiration, often critically evaluating an existing society and putting
forward a vision of a future society.
Prophets are critics who are passionate about social justice and who
have the courage to challenge existing domination systems and ruling elites9.
Prophesy can
be a fundamental and valued spiritual practice in service of radical social
change. The moral vision of “what isn’t working” and “the way it should be” aid
a people to understand their world and change it in accord with spiritual
principles and visions of social justice. Rather than “predicting the future”,
as is often misunderstood, the energizing messages of prophets generate hope
and create a new vision of the future.
Social
injustice can be defined as the state in which people are treated without
dignity and respect and are not provided access to basic human needs. Social
injustice thus incorporates a “redistributive claim” which seeks more just
distribution of resources and goods, and a claim in the “politics of
recognition”, in which so-called minority groups are accorded equal
respect. As we learn how to see
injustices, we become aware that they plague our planet. Manifestations of social injustice include
severe poverty, world hunger, homelessness, lack of access to healthcare,
oppression and exploitation based on ethnicity, gender or social class, and
violation of human rights.
Systems of
oppression, including capitalism, patriarchy, imperialism (etc.) operate on
individual, institutional and societal levels through conscious and unconscious
actions and beliefs to exploit some people and benefit others based on
membership or perceived membership in social groups, including those based upon
race, gender, class, age, ability, sexual orientation and religion (to name
some, but not all groups). These systems
are interconnected and mutual reinforcing.
Through these processes members of dominant groups receive unearned
privileges. These unearned privileges
come, not as a result of merit or effort, but as a result of systems of
oppression.
Allow me to
offer some prophetic observations about modernity by very briefly critiquing
“what isn’t working” and briefly formulating a vision of “how it should
be”. Specifically, three major problems
are articulated: (1) our ecological crisis, especially global climate change;
(2) systems of oppression that perpetuate inequality, oppression and
exploitation; and (3) a mass psychology of misery, in which nihilism,
alienation and cynicism abound.
Our current
environmental situation is bleak—global climate change is wreaking havoc across
our planet—fires engulf Australia, Arctic glaciers dissipate rapidly, crop
failures everywhere. And two decades
into this hot-house world and industrialized nations still use fossil fuels as
if nothing changed. We’ve entered the
“sixth extinction” and thousands of species are disappearing. Industrial
civilization rapidly extracts everything it can from our fragile ecosystems and
leaves behind toxic wastes and all forms of pollution.
As if that
weren’t enough, modernity has unleashed levels of greed almost
unimaginable. Several months ago Oxfam
announced that the world’s top 62 billionaires have more wealth that the bottom
half of the world’s population10.
Our current forms of social organization are predicated on oppression,
exploitation and social exclusion.
Capitalism, while continually providing us with lots of shiny new toys,
hurts lots of people badly, leaving millions barely holding onto the social
ladder.
Accompanying
modernity’s ecological devastation and oppressive structures is a mass
psychology of misery, in which nihilism, cynicism and alienation abound. A lot
of people are not very happy and have numerous mental health symptoms. These unhealthy mindsets are obstacles for the great transformational work
which lies before us, in which we must feel our connections to all that exists,
optimistically move forward saying “Yes to life!, knowing that we are blessed to
be here sharing the bounty of this glorious world.
Prophetic
envisioning allows us to create an imaginary of a better world, in which all
people are treated with dignity and respect, a sense of fairness pervades all
institutional operations, human suffering is minimized and we live in harmony
with all life on the planet. These are sacred visions that best emerge in
collective dialogue and with spiritual practices that involve deep
contemplation. These visions are ever
evolving. Through history a story emerges
of an evolving communal quest for greater justice. Generation after generation the body politic
has gradually become more just. People
and populations who were previously silenced, marginalized and treated as
non-persons have been given a voice, have moved to the center and have become
enfranchised.
Another way to
invoke a vision of a just, compassionate and sustainable society would be in
terms of strengthening three sets of institutions vital to social democracy:
(1) A democratic political system in which
power is shared and balanced and opposition is encouraged and celebrated;
(2) the economy is sufficiently regulated
to ensure the protection of consumers;
(3) a system to redistribute overall
wealth to generously support the health and well-being of all citizens.
The fairness
of these institutions is paramount to a just society, insuring that all
citizens are treated with dignity and respect.
I don’t think
that we should create detailed blueprints of our future society and its
accompanying institutions. As the core
of our crisis is found in our modes of thinking, particularly our sense that
economic growth is essential to a vibrant economy, I think that our focus
should be on addressing our cultural worldviews. As Johannes Krause observes massive systems
change cannot be managed nor controlled and it is impossible for us now living
in modernity to know what will be at the end of the transformative process11.
ON CONTEMPLATIVE PRACTICES
Contemplation
is any practice designed to quiet the mind and cultivate a capacity for deep
concentration and insight. While usually
practiced in silence, some types of contemplative practice involve voice or
other use of sound. Types of
contemplative practice include prayer, meditation, mindful walking, yoga,
vision quests and council circles.
Through
contemplation the individual brings aspects of themselves into focus and
becomes more fully aware of the interconnectedness of life. Contemplation can
be a solitary experience or one that is communal. The intention with which a practice is done
is a very important factor.
Contemplation connects us with an inner source of wisdom – a deep
spiritual dimension. While contemplative
practices are today employed as practical tools for stress reduction and
relaxation, their transformational potential is vast.
The spiritual
potential of contemplation includes:
·
Deep,
focused attention that dissolves our preconceptions so that we can observe
situations as they more truly are;
·
Putting
ourselves in another’s shoes as a way to bear witness to the suffering and pain
of others;
·
Paying
attention to what is in your heart;
·
Remaining
open to outcomes and remaining unattached;
·
Conceiving
of loving action toward others and ourselves;
·
Recommit
ourselves to nonviolence, reverence for life, solidarity, justice, democratic
practice and sustainability.
Silence,
mindfulness, contemplation and discernment allow them mind to calm down and
focus clearly on what is at hand. At
times we direct our thoughts to certain topics or concerns and metaphorically
send them out to the world. When we
clear our minds of thoughts and attempt to just be with the breath, we focus on
the embodied sensations of the moment.
At other times we attempt to open our minds and hearts and be receptive
to the wisdom of the universe (discernment)
Prayer is a
particularly powerful spiritual practice which creates a sacred space, provides
hope for what we are doing and connects us to the spirit of love. When praying I attempt to:
(1) Rejoice in the glorious wonder of the
universe;
(2) Focus on what is in my heart;
(3) Remain humble;
(4) Speak the truth;
(5) Acknowledge the suffering of the
world;
(6) Express gratitude for all I have;
(7) Recognize the changes I have to make;
(8) Imagine a better world made through
good works;
(9) Recommit myself to others, and above all;
(10)
Express
love for my neighbors (and adversaries)
Contemplative
spiritual practices can benefit political activists by allowing them to slow
down and reflect on their circumstances. The numerous benefits of mindfulness
have been documented by science.
ON DIRECT ACTION AS A SPIRITUAL
PRACTICE
Practical
theology shifts the concern in religion from sets of beliefs to real-world
actions. The focus on praxis means that
we must live our ideals. We affirm our worldviews through our actions. By strategic direct actions I am referring to
long-term, large-scale plans to reach our goals of changing our social world.
Revolutionary social change requires a wide range of strategies, including
civil disobedience, strikes, boycotts, lobbying, direct confrontation, obstruction
and occupation.
By analyzing
the root causes of our problems we hope to change the structural features of
our social world, and not merely apply band-aids. Because of our commitments to
collective liberation, we must build alliances with other groups, especially
those who have been marginalized in our society. We remain committed to empowering
disenfranchised people to change the social structures that deny them justice.
As a Dionysian
Naturalist, I insist upon bringing carnivaleque pleasures and joyful
celebration to my transformational politics.
Since Seattle 1999 street protests in North America have become more
theatrical and fun, with costumed clowns on stilts poking fun at militarized
police squads. Song and dance and
spiritual rituals do much to temper the tone of protest marches.
What religion
brings to these social change actions is a focus on living our values. If we want to create a world that is just and
compassionate, we must use strategies that are also just and compassionate. The “means” matter. As stated above, the revolution is how we
live our lives. Through social movement
participation we reveal our values and embody the ends we seek. I draw
inspiration from Jesus’s words: “Love your enemies.”
Contemporary
anarchist activism is very strong on these forms of “prefigurative politics” in
which we put our values into action through praxis, and have means that
resonate with the ends. Anarchists are
committed to address all forms of domination, and attempt to deal with these,
even among activists themselves. And
these internal concerns are truly exciting because who wants to listen to
radical activists who talk a good revolution but do not have their own house in
order. Sexism, racism and homophobia
(and other forms of oppression) pervade all institutional forms on the North
American continent, including progressive social movements.
Nonviolence is
a cardinal principle for the forms of social change I advance. Collective liberation must not harm
others. We must learn from the great
nonviolent revolutionaries who have changed the world for us, including Gandhi,
Martin Luther King, Jr., and Caesar Chavez.
Change agents must remain noble, dignified and above rebuke as they
critique existing institutions. They
must never attack personalities, but must focus on principles.
All forms of
direct action must be thought fully considered.
Is the destruction of private property justified? Obviously the “disruption” of the normal
routines of public lives must be interrupted.
But how much? Even “protests”
must be spiritually motivated and never mean or hateful.
SELF-BOUND THINKING IN
MODERNITY IS A SPIRITUAL DISEASE
Modernity is a
“civilizational epoch” noted for industrial capitalism and increases in the
rationalization of social practices. It
has been an epoch of many scientific discoveries and technological inventions
that continue to alter our lifestyles.
For the first time in history humans have a sense of the age and size of
the Universe, and are beginning to understand the processes by which it
operates. We are beginning to grasp our
place in the cosmos and know that we are the Universe reflecting back on
itself. As noted above, modernity has
caused massive ecological damage, created levels of inequality unrivaled by any
other time in human history, and produced a mass psychology of misery, in which
alienation, nihilism and cynicism abound.
Quite frankly, modernity isn’t working and must be crushed.
Modernity must
be brought to a close and a new society made in its place. We need a new social system based on
sustainability, justice and love. There
seems to be broad agreement among progressive change agents that if we are
going to undertake a massive transformation of our social structures to deal
with our ecological crisis, we should seize this opportunity to address other
major social problems. Within the last few years there has emerged a growing
literature exploring this potential transformation in social systems, often
called The Great Turning or The Great Transition.
The root cause
of many of our current social ills is a particularly modern form of egotism –a
self-bound and self-centered type of thinking which dominates the populations
of western industrial civilization, as well as the ruling classes of most of
the world. This mindset allows people to
focus so exclusively on their own needs and situations that they fail to take
into account the perspectives of others—both human and other living beings.
Regarding our
ecological problems we fail to grasp the perspectives of other life forms. With our prevailing anthropocentric thinking
we totally ignore the perspectives of other species. Within the modern era, certainly in “western”
societies, we tend to regard Nature as merely a resource that is there to serve
human needs and desires. We fail to
value the inherent worth of every life form.
We are so wrapped up in our almighty human perspectives that seeing the
world from the point of view of polar bears, jack rabbits and starlings goes
far beyond our current imagination.
Regarding our
problems of inequality and oppression we fail to grasp the perspectives of
other human beings who are less fortunate than us. Our self-bound thinking and egotistical
mindsets prevent those in power or who have unearned privileges from grasping
the perspectives of those without power or privilege,
Genetics,
modern childrearing practices and a culture of radical individualism cultivate
a myopic self-consciousness which blocks the empathy required to grasp the
suffering of other beings, both human and other life forms. The result has been an egotism and
anthropocentrism which, as stated above, are the root causes of our ecological
crisis and many other social problems.
The biological
evolution of human beings over hundreds of thousands of years has created a
mental system in which our “default position” includes a “tendency to analyze
everything as an immediate, personal phenomenon: what does this mean to me”
(Ornstein and Ehrlich 1989, p. 93)11. While our biological nature is relatively
fixed and difficult to mold, another aspect of our psychology is adaptive and
molds to fit the needs of society. This “social character” (Erich Fromm)
exacerbates the self-referencing of our biological nature. Capitalism has a ruling ethos stating: “if
only everyone strives for himself on the market, the common good will come of
it”12. Our private dealings
are governed by egotism, with people typically out for themselves.
And this
egotism begets anthropocentrism, which is a form of that same self-bound
thinking brought to the species level.
We have become alienated from the natural world and have become
disconnected from other living beings and therefore discount their inherent
value, while inflating our own value.
In order to
empathize with another we must step outside of our heads and take their
perspective. Without the ability to empathize we lack compassion, and treat the
world harshly and coldly. This lack of empathy and absence of compassion
amounts to a “spiritual disease” because it eliminates reverence from our
lives. At the heart of many religious
traditions is the Golden Rule which instructs us to treat others the way we
wish to be treated. Exploring the emergence of the Golden Rule across the globe
during the “Axial Age”, religious historian Karen Armstrong argues that sages
such as Confucius, the Buddha and Jesus each created “spiritual technologies”
that utilized natural human energies to counter aggression (Karen Armstrong p.
390)13. Their programs were
designed to eliminate the egotism which causes violence.
I want to
build on this insight, yet to expand its scope to include all living
beings. We need to treat all living
beings with respect and reverence, not just other humans. We must eliminate the anthropocentrism which
pervades our thinking and develop an ecological consciousness.
“THINKING LIKE A MOUNTAIN” AS
SPIRITUAL PRACTICE
To re-kindle
their awareness of their spiritual connections to other humans and to other
living beings, many modern humans may require a program designed to eradicate their
egotism and anthropocentrism. Here I
propose as a spiritual practice an exercise I call “thinking like a mountain”,
which is designed just for those purposes.
In his classic
Sand County Almanac (originally published in 1949), Aldo Leopold urges
us to “think like a mountain”. At one
point in that book we are following Leopold as he follows the tracks of a skunk
in the January snow. We learn to think
of different animals as subjects rather than objects, as beings that have their
own goals and their own perspectives on the world. As a youth, Leopold kills a wolf and watches
the “fierce green fire” die in her eyes.
This event leads to an epiphany in which he comes to realize how, while
killing the wolf might seem beneficial to the hunter as it allows the deer
population to swell, for the mountain and for the wolf, it might not be such a
good thing. The deer population’s boom
could lead to a drastic reduction in vegetation available for other species.
Like the young
Leopold who shot the wolf, we often are so focused on our roles and our needs
that we unintentionally ignore the roles of others. To “think like a mountain” is to see the
“big picture”, to take a holistic perspective, to grasp the delicate interconnectedness
of the web of existence. It entails being able to simultaneously take the
perspective of a whole ecosystem. When we grasp our deep connections to the
world this amounts to a “moment of grace” in that we realize that our
well-being is linked to the well-being of our planet.
To cultivate a
habit of reverence for others, whether those others are human or non-human,
animate or inanimate, we must transcend the egotism and anthropocentrism so
prevalent in modernity. To have empathy
for another entity or to understand another’s perspective requires that we get
out of our own heads. It is only by stepping outside the confines of our
routine patterns of self-bound thinking and consciousness that we can transcend
the self-absorption which blocks our sensitivity to our environment and the other
living beings found therein. As we
become aware of the plurality of perspectives, our sense of having a privileged
perspective melts away.
By letting go
of our self-obsession and putting ourselves in the role of other beings and
grasping their vital role in the interconnected web of existence, we take a
step towards the humility demanded for an ecological consciousness. By nurturing this new “other-directed”
mind-set and more humble state of being, we can even acquire a constant sacred
consciousness, fully feeling the presence of all life around us
The heart of
this spiritual practice is a guided meditation, in which we take a journey back
through deep time to explore the evolutionary pathways of the atoms in our
bodies and the previous life forms from which we have descended. Perhaps some of our atoms emerged almost
fourteen billion years ago briefly after the Big Bang, while others emerged
from generations of supernova. Moving
forward we imagine each of our predecessors as ancestors, whether these
ancestors are algae, fir trees, jelly fish, or dinosaurs.
Our bodies are
merely the latest incarnation of our being. When we realize that we are kin
with all other life forms and even closely related to all other elements in the
universe, we escape our self-bound thinking and the egotism and
anthropocentrism so prevalent in our thinking.
When we truly grasp the interconnected web of existence and the inherent
value of all it contains, we begin to “think like a mountain”.
While most
humans exclusively identify with their humanness, the point of this inner
journey is to recognize our intimate relationship with other species, all other
life forms and even the soils beneath our feet and the stars above our
heads. The ancient savannah still dwells
within our veins. As our memories return
a change in consciousness will occur as we replace the anthropocentric
structures of our minds with awareness of how evolution and ecology combined to
bring our species to this point.
CONCLUSION
The mounting
scientific evidence on global climate change reveals that we face a “terminal
crisis” in which most life on the planet is threatened, and that already
catastrophic destruction of civilization is inevitable. The magnitude of the environmental crisis
compounded by the time limitations that exist before we face a total
environmental collapse, lead me to the conclusion that revolution is
required. Modernity must be crushed and
a new civilizational epoch based on sustainability must emerge.
As
revolutionaries we must steer the populace towards a better world and lead the
transition from a period of life-denying human practices to a period of
life-affirming practices. This gap
between the way things are and the way they should be leads us to revolt. We accept responsibility for the state of the
world and stress how our everyday habits and attitudes contribute to the
situation.
My concern in
this paper has been to consider what religion brings to the table for
revolutionaries in this age of climate crisis.
While religions typically function as the carriers of tradition, and
thus constrain social change, they can also inspire movements for social
justice, help us to clarify our values, and serve to mobilize the masses.
Importantly, religion connects people to community and for the processes of
social change that means collective efforts can go into affirming our values,
deciding which issues to tackle and by what means. People of faith are vital participants in
social movements and very often its leaders.
Religion also
brings to revolution a drastic shift in both style and content. Spiritual activism elevates the playing field
and turns radicals into “holy warriors”.
It brings nobility, dignity and grace to social change struggles. Religion infuses transformational politics
with compassion, mindfulness and sacred intent.
The strategic direct actions of people of faith are principled and
informed by deeply cherished values.
While the
greening of religion instills ecological concerns within mainstream religion,
that is not enough. I have cast my own
personal theology, Dionysian Naturalism, as an insurgent Nature Religion. Insurgent Nature Religions insist upon the
sacredness of this world and therefore regard the destruction of Nature as
desecration. This sense of the sacred
derives from: (1) the mystery and majesty of our natural world, which elicits
strong feelings of wonder and awe; (2) our absolute dependence upon Nature as a
source of sustenance, inspiration, recreation and revelation; and (3) our
awareness of our humble fragility compared with Nature’s vast powers. This sense of the sacred also motivates our
goals of radical social change. As a
most holy object, Nature must be protected and preserved and never
violated.
Nature is the
source of our lives and all that we find valuable, important and meaningful,
and this connection and dependence lead us to know that we belong here. We
recognize that all living beings are our kin and that we share ancestral roots.
This combined sense of belonging and kinship necessitate a global ethic of
caring which demands that we treat all life with respect and reverence, and
recognize the valued place of each life form in the complex and interconnected
web of existence. This ethic of caring informs
our goals of revolutionary praxis, as well as mandating a major re-thinking of
the moral and ethical foundations of modern industrial civilization (whose
dominant values have justified and supported our ecocidal way of life).
I briefly
outlined a “practical theology” of social change founded on the notion of
praxis. Praxis is situated activity in
which we act with purposeful intention, live our values and consider the
potential ethical consequences of our planned actions. This practical theology consists of a
sequence of nine principles to guide faith communities and other groups to
engage in grassroots community organizing to empower displaced, marginalized
and silenced groups to transform their own lives and the structural conditions
which deny them justice.
I elaborated
on four spiritual practices which were included in these principles which I
claimed were particularly relevant to the work of social activists. Those
cycles of action – reflection referred to as praxis can inspire social movement
participants to “get their own house in order”.
Praxis motivates progressive activists to align their behavior with
their beliefs, values, and theories, and therefore motivates anti-oppressive
efforts, such as feminist and anti-racist education and application.
Contemplative practices allow often too busy change agents an opportunity to
pause so that they might deeply reflect on their lived experiences in the
world. Reflecting on past actions
provides time and space to learn about ourselves and our environment.
Prophetic
critique and envisioning provide political activists with sacred techniques to
formulate the problems of our existing society which must be addressed by
contrasting them with a vision of a future utopian society. Prophesy can also name the spiritual
practices that should be used to bring about the changes, which brings us to
the fourth set of practices I reviewed. Religion brings to revolution nobility,
grace, reverence and “class”. It
replaces angry resentment with committed compassion, and replaces unruly mobs
the disciplined people of faith seeking to transform the structures which
create the injustices. Spiritual
activism incarnates praxis through strategic direct actions filled with
intention, compassion and mindful presence.
As people of
faith who affirm life we advocate nonviolent methods to achieve major
structural changes in the organization of society. Such actions in defense of the Earth are
spiritual practices, and we are nothing less than Holy Warriors. As participants in an “engaged spirituality”,
adherents to Insurgent Nature Religions affirm their beliefs through their
actions (praxis) and align themselves with other social movements concerned
with justice and ecological integrity.
Revolution for us is the way we live our lives.
Embracing a
theology of power, we value democratic process, speak truth to Power and assist
those who have been traditionally marginalized, displaced and silenced to find
their voices. Celebrating the rhythms of
Nature’s cycles we perform embodied rituals celebrating the sacredness of life
and the importance of local places. We
know that everything is constituted in relationships and systems of
relationships. Each strand in the web
has value and importance for the strength, well-being and integrity of the
entire whole. We know that we make a
difference and reject cynical apathy and indifference.
The effects of
climate change create a massive existential crisis in which we fear facing the
inevitable future which lies before us. It is very challenging to accept the
potential level of ecological devastation before us and equally challenging to
accept that we are not responding as needed.
This is a time
for revolution. The climate crisis
threatens to destroy much of our planet and we face an environmental
catastrophe unprecedented in human history.
We have known for over 20 years how pumping carbon into our atmosphere
affects our climates. And, for 50 years
we have known about how industrial civilization poisons the ecosystems in which
it exists. We are coming to realize that
the extraction of valued resources.
r-
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS AND NOTES
Relationship
and interdependence are not just ecological concepts relevant to understanding
the natural world, but mark the contours of our wild and precious lives. So many spiritual activists in Santa Barbara
have taught me what I know about the practicalities of transformational
politics and social justice work. UCSB
Professor Dick Flacks, campus radical and social movement intellectual, was one
of the reasons I moved to Santa Barbara to do graduate work over 30 years ago
and I still draw inspiration from his example.
The theology of change I advance emerges from my direct experiences as
an activist and community organizer focusing on ending homelessness in my
community. I suffer from some mental
health challenges which have left me homeless multiple times in the past 15
years. While my time on the streets or
living in shelters is relatively brief compared to many, those experiences
allowed me to bear witness to social injustice through coming to know many
beautiful people whose lives were very difficult and often very short. Even in
a community as small as Santa Barbara (100,000 people) there were years in
which a death of a person experiencing homelessness happened almost once a
week. As a formerly homeless person,
working as a social worker doing street outreach, I often knew these people. In
2007 I began to attend the Homeless Activist Luncheon, hosted by Chuck Blitz
and Cath Webb, which introduced me to a group of concerned community change
agents, including Ken Williams, Roger Heroux, Gary Linker, Lynne Jahnke, Rev.
Jon Lemmond, Fr. Jon-Stephen Hedges and
Lynnelle Williams, who each have done so much to improve the lives on those on
the streets. The board members of the
Santa Barbara chapter of Clergy and Laity United for Economic Justice (CLUE-SB)
live their values through their commitment to structural change, and I am
especially indebted to Rev. Mark Asman,
Rev. Julia Hamilton, Anne Anderson, Maureen Earls, John Michals and Becca Claussen.
Two women who have done much to improve mental health services in SB County are
Suzanne Riordan and Catherine Birtalan.
Other local luminaries who have taught me much include Professor John
Foran, Cheryl Schnell, Chuck Flacks, Sayre MacNeil, Catherine Albanese, David William Powell and
Jeffrey Albaugh. The idea for this
project emerged from dialogue with Rhyd Wildermuth , founding editor of Gods&Radicals.
The editors of Humanistic Paganism, John Halstead and Jon Cleland Host,
have nurtured and supported my writing.
1. See for
example, Joanna Macy and Chris Johnstone (2012) Active Hope: How to Face the
Mess We’re In Without Going Crazy.
Novato, CA: New World Library.
2. Albert
Einstein. Controversy concerning this
quote and it’s source are found at: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Talk:Albert_Einstein#Unsourced_and_dubious.2Foverly_modern_sources retrieved on June 14, 2016.
3. As a proud Unitarian Universalist (UU),
having been a member of the Unitarian Society of Santa Barbara for over a
decade, I embrace the seven core principles of our faith. Initially I was drawn to its “free and
responsible search for truth and meaning” which allowed me intellectual space
to figure out what I believed. Unitarian Universalism is a “non-creedal”
religion and a home to freethinkers of all types, for whom matters of faith are
determined by personal conscience. UU
congregations often contain liberal Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Atheists,
Humanists, and Pagans. A common message
is often that there is beauty and truth in all religions. We often say “deeds not creeds” and emphasize
living our shared values through active social justice engagement. Throughout the 20th century,
Humanists formed the intellectual core of our faith with their insistence that
reason and science have a crucial role to play in theological formation. Yet,
the current UU “multi-faith” approach to theology seems to abandon these
defining concerns for reason and science.
Can someone believe in supernatural deities, unsubstantiated miracles
and woo-woo hocus pocus and be a UU?
Apparently so.
My personal
theology is grounded in the rapidly growing approach known as Religious
Naturalism, which is firmly grounded in a scientific worldview. Its roots are found in Spinoza, Thoreau,
Whitman, Dewey and Santayana, among others.
Many of the leading contemporary UU theologians are engaged in
developing this religious approach, including Jerome Stone, Robert Corrington,
and Michael Hogue. Other prominent
Religious Naturalist theologians include Loyal Rue, Donald Crosby, Karl Peters,
and Ursula Goodenough.
My version of
Religious Naturalism is called Dionysian Naturalism, and it tempers the
Apollonian emphasis on reason and science with concerns for passions, bodily
sensations and the emotions. Incorporating shamanistic elements and drawing
upon the ecstatic religions of our ancestors, it affirms the sacred role of
personal mystical experiences and other non-ordinary states of consciousness,
including by entheogenic consumption. Our celebratory rituals are often filled
with transgressive pleasure. Nietzsche
greatly inspired my initial forays into Dionysian spirituality and while I have
not located a textual reference, it could be that he called his religion of the
future “Dionysian Naturalism”.
My previous
essays developing this theological approach include “Steps Toward a Dionysian
Naturalism (2015),”Our Universe is a Sacred Living System” (2015, “Enchanting
Naturalism” (2015), “Dancing with Dionysus: Ecstasy and Religion in the Age of
the Anthropocene” (2016), .all of which appear on the website Humanistic
Paganism. A briefer version of “Dancing With Dionysus” also appears in John
Halstead (Ed.) Godless Paganism: Voices of Non-Theistic Pagan.
4. The now
classic book on Nature Religions, by my fellow Santa Barbara Unitarian
Universalist, Catherine Albanese, is Nature Religions in America: From the
Algonkian Indian to the New Age. (1990) Chicago: University of Chicago
Press. For an excellent guide to Nature Religions, see Bron Taylor (2010) Dark
Green Religion: Nature Spirituality and the Planetary Future. Berkeley:
University of California Press.
5. Caitlin and
John Matthews (1994). Walkers Between
the Worlds: The Western Mysteries from Shaman to Magus. Rochester, Vermont: Inner Traditions.
6. Some of
these thoughts come from other essays I’ve written on praxis, including for the
blog Everyday Sociology and the local Santa Barbara news outlet Noozhawk.
7. Martin Luther
King, Jr. (1967). “A Christmas Sermon on
Peace.” Retrieved from
http://www.ecoflourish.com/Primers/education/Christmas_Sermon.html on June 14, 2016
8. Erica
Sherover-Marcuse. (1986). Emancipation
and Consciousness: Dogmatic and Dialectical Perspectives in the Early
Marx. New York: Basil Blackwell.
9. Marcus Borg
(2001). Reading the Bible Again for the First Time. San Francisco: Harper.
11. Johannes
Krause. (2014). “Transformation: Reflections on Theory and Practice of System
Change.” Retrieved from http://deeep.org on June 14, 2016.
12. Ornstein
and Ehrlich (1989). New World New Mind: Moving Toward Conscious Evolution.
London: Doubleday.
13. Erich
Fromm (1955) The Sane Society. NY: Holt.
13. Karen
Armstrong. (2006). The
Great Transformation: The Beginning of Our Religious Traditions. Anchor Books
14. Aldo
Leopold. (1966). A Sand County Almanac: With Other Essays on Conservation from
Round River. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.

Comments
Post a Comment